Helping Our Peninsula's Environment

 

Model Noise (Free) Element for a General Plan

By David Dilworth (with assistance from Herman Medwin, Ph.D.)

Copyright 2004-2006 Helping Our Peninsula's Environment

(Permission to use in a legislative body's policy is hereby granted - but only where credit is given to Helping Our Peninsula's Environment, David Dilworth and Herman Medwin Ph.D., and notice is received by Helping Our Peninsula's Environment. Any other use requires written permission.)

Informed Consent Noise Policy

This Noise Prevention Policy or General Plan Element can be used by any nation, state, city or county (for example - Canada, California, Carmel-by-the-Sea, or Calaveras County).

This policy is intended to be as simple as possible for cities and counties to merely add this into their General Plan policies with virtually no editing other than to insert the name of their jurisdiction. 

It is intended to be a higher level policy that guides preparation of a Noise Control Ordinance or a Code by defining the scope and limits of what they must address. While it is not intended as a Noise Ordinance or a Code, parts of it can be used for that. 

In California, all cities and counties are required to prepare and adopt a "General Plan" and stay within the limits it defines. General Plans need to be updated every 5 years or so. Each General Plan has seven required elements including Noise. You may notice that this Element has four improvements over typical Noise control policies and laws: 

  1. It recognizes and limits the noise at the "ear of the beholder" in addition to the noise level at the noisy activity location,
  2. It recognizes and limits maximum noise levels as opposed to merely "average" noise levels,
  3. It recognizes and limits inaudible (ultrasonic and infrasonic) noise, and
  4. It allows noise pollution, but only when fully informed consent is given by all affected parties.

Your comments for improvements are welcome.

Noise Goal

The purpose of this noise element is to restore and maintain (your jurisdiction's 1 ) overall and specific quiet healthful environment and natural aesthetics; to eliminate harmful and disturbing man-made unwanted sound, known as noise, in and adjacent to (our jurisdiction).

Noise Findings

  1. This Plan agrees with the World Health Organization in recognizing that noise is not merely a nuisance, it is a "serious health hazard." Noise levels and types can cause harm as well as annoyance, and even death to humans and wildlife, and can interfere with individual and community activities and harm property and reduce its value. It is notable that less than 100 years ago, the loudest common noise was horse hooves clattering on brick lined streets. There were no chainsaws roaring in residential neighborhoods, leaf blowers, diesel trucks, motor cars, or airplanes.
    1. Damage: Continuous or transient noise at and above 75 dBA at the ear of the listener can cause hearing damage;
    2. Annoying and Significant: Noise above 55 dBA can be annoying and the U.S. EPA considers it a significant impact;
    3. Conversation Blocking: Noise levels of 50 dBA barely permits intelligible conversation; and
    4. Inaudible Harm: Inaudible low frequency infrasound and high frequency ultrasonic noise can cause biological and property damage.

 

2. This Plan recognizes that relative levels of noise intrusion compared to the existing noise levels, are sometimes more important than absolute noise levels.


For example 50 dBA might be unnoticed in town but can be annoying or harmful in a quiet natural area - a park, a trail, rural areas, or at a beach. Thus it is important to measure existing sound level baselines rather than time averaged man-made noise levels, which may be too high already. 
 

3. This Plan recognizes that harm and complaints are more often caused by actual short duration or intermittent maximum noise levels rather than calculated average noise levels

4. This Plan recognizes each Californian's inalienable Right to Safety.
   

5. This Plan recognizes the California legislature's determination to take all action necessary to provide the people of this state with enjoyment of aesthetic, and natural environmental qualities, and freedom from excessive noise. 

6. This Plan recognizes that there is no right to pollute, harm or annoy others.  

7. This Plan recognizes the fundamental rights of every individual --

    1. To be fully informed of a harmful action before it occurs, and 
    2. To deny consent.

8. This Plan recognizes the existence of abundant alternative technology which is significantly less noisy. 

 

Quiet Restoration and Protection Actions

  1. Within one year of adoption of this Plan and updated at least yearly -
    1. A complete inventory shall be prepared of -
      1. All areas of natural sound, and 
      2. Noise sources of all existing man-made activities experiencing transient and continuous noise of at least 45 dBA; and Physical measurements shall be taken, as opposed to estimates or computer models, and maps shall be prepared of natural sound levels in all public areas and legally accessible private lands, and of continuous and repeating transient maximum noise levels for all noise sources in the updated inventory of noise levels of all man-made activities including, but not limited to --

Air Conditioners, Amplified Music, Barking Dogs, Chainsaws & Wood Chippers, Construction Vehicles, Construction Power Tools & Equipment, Generators, Industrial Fans, Industrial Engines, Leaf Blowers, Lawn Mowers, Portable Radios, Power Transformers, Public Address Systems, Public Fields or Stadiums (e.g. Football, Baseball, Soccer), Racing Tracks, Rock Quarries, Theaters, Vehicles, Weapon use (including Firing Ranges and Hunting), Aircraft, Busses, Cars, Neighborhood traffic, Traffic near Parks, Car Music, Event Traffic, Idling Busses, & Trucks, Motorcycles, Street Sweepers, Trucks, Garbage Trucks, Rockets, Spacecraft and Trains.

b. The measurements shall separately measure and map all noise locations in our jurisdiction, and sound levels, for --

        1. The Maximum Instantaneous Noise levels, 
        2. Noise Durations, 
        3. CNEL (if required by law), and
        4. The dBA difference of an area's average natural sound level to that of the man-made intruding noise level at the time of the intrusion.

 

2. To prevent harm, annoyance and activity interference by noise, no activity, existing or proposed, is permitted, except to alleviate an emergency, which can cause any transient or continuous noise exceeding --

A. Noise levels of 55 dBA on any party unwilling or unable to give their consent.

B. Natural sound levels by 5 dBA, where any alternative exists.

For example: Truck routes can be specified and truck speed limits can be lower than for other vehicles. An alternative to idling a bus or a truck is to require the motor to be turned off. An alternative to a 117 dBA chainsaw - is the use of an axe which only causes 55 dBA maximum.

3. To adequately warn people consenting to sound levels exceeding 55 dBA about the potential harm to their health, prior to the noise activity, each person whose consent is required must be given a readable copy of a true declaration clearly describing maximum noise levels and durations, and all potential harms to their health from the activity. Consent is only valid when a copy of the declaration is signed by the party affected by the noise. Proxy signatures are not valid. 

4. To eliminate outside noises which adversely affect our area, (our jurisdiction e.g. Carmel or Monterey County) shall encourage avoidance and alternatives to all agencies and jurisdictions which have control over those noisy activities. 

5. This Plan is intended to reflect the best available science. Whenever significantly improved information, alternatives, methods and equipment become available all policy related to this subject shall be updated within one year.  

 

6. At all times (the jurisdiction, e.g. Carmel or Monterey County) shall provide adequate resources to fully enforce this element and employ at least one full-time safety officer trained in noise detection and enforcement and noise free alternatives. 

 

7. Compliance shall be encouraged with meaningful substantial fines collected, equal to the yearly cost of the noise making equipment by each responsible party for violations of each provision of this policy. Such fines shall be wholly applied to providing non-noisy alternatives and noise monitoring.  

 

8. Any person may bring suit to enforce compliance with this policy. When successful enforcement of this ordinance is brought and accomplished by any person or entity other than the District Attorney the successful plaintiff shall be awarded $5,000 civil penalty from defendant and any other fees and costs deemed appropriate by the court including those awarded pursuant to (California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5)2

_______

Note 1. Where you find the word "jurisdiction" in parenthesis you replace it with the name of your city or county - for example - Carmel, or Monterey County. 

Note 2: The Attorney's Fees Provision must be modified to fit your state or country's laws.

 

Feedback - Info6(at)1hope.org

831 / 624-6500 P.O. Box 1495, Carmel, CA 93921

Search HOPE's Website:


powered by
FreeFind

Or Search the whole Web with IxQuick

This Page Last Updated January 22, 2007

Home Law Page General Plan Model Elements

*